Marcom case study: the “Hyatt Shuttle” of New York’s Grand Central Station

It’s not often these days I’m stopped in my tracks (no pun intended) by an ad or related form of marketing communication. Most of them seem to fuse with the background becoming invisible in mere seconds. This week was an exception, however, and it underscores one of the core principles any marketer should keep in mind when crafting effective marketing communications…


My encounter with "The Shuttle"
As I boarded the Shuttle train this morning, half-awake from my morning coffee, I was brought to full attention by a completely transformed subway interior (for those unfamiliar, the shuttle is a train that runs between Time Square & Grand Central Station in NYC). Beyond the expected surprise I felt from entering a subway car that had been bathed in the accoutrement of a solitary theme, there were a few reasons in particular that made the experience so memorable. And, it serves as a great example of how marketers can cut through the clutter – objective number one for any marketing communication. This feat was all the more impressive given that it was competing head-to-head with the madness that is midtown Manhattan during morning rush hour.


Why the Hyatt Shuttle = effective marketing communication
So what made the experience so compelling?

For starters, the train’s interior broke any existing schema (or expectation) I had for “what the inside of a NYC subway looks like”. Instead of steely, cool panels, the train was affixed with faux wood “wall paper” reminiscent of some bachelor’s finished basement from the late 70s, pool table & wet bar not included.

In place of slick, high-design ads pressed into the metal picture frames that dot the subway’s interior were color graphs printed on basic white printer paper; graphs that reminded me of the simple bar charts Microsoft Excel spit out circa 1989 . The charts, whose effectiveness was heightened by their simplicity, depicted how much more successful face-to-face meetings are in comparison with video conferencing, email, or phone calls.

At its essence, Hyatt transformed a cold, unfriendly space (the inside of a NYC subway) into a warm, inviting place - the inference being that Hyatt Conference Centers create the type of warm, inviting atmospheres conducive to effective business schmoozing & networking.

Now I’m neither an event planner nor coordinator of large-scale meetings, so I cannot speak to the level of influence "The Hyatt Shuttle” might have on my decision-making for those upcoming conferences.

However, to some degree that’s irrelevant. “The Hyatt Shuttle” compelled me to whip out my blackberry on a crowded train and snap away - much to the annoyance of my fellow commuters. It got me to write this post with blurry crackberry photos attached for the entire world to see (or 0.00022% of the Internet world per my latest Alexa rankings). And perhaps most compelling - Hyatt was able to convert me into an online PR guy who’s apparently willing to work for free. All Hyatt had to do was serve up a unique experience that added a little bit of zest to my otherwise predictable day. Clever, high-ROI strategy… and heck of a marketing communications case study for marketers to sink their teeth into & leverage for their own business.


The Law of the Unexpected
Let’s bubble-up this mini case study and see what useful principles we can derive for you to use in your business… at its core, what made The Hyatt Shuttle so compelling is that it successfully employed the law of the unexpected, which simply states that throw something out there that I don’t expect and you’ll capture my attention... think giraffe in a field of cows, an orange in a bowl of apples, or your waiter at The Four Seasons dressed in a white t-shirt & cut-off jean shorts.


How to apply the law of the unexpected to your marketing communication
Let's get right to what you're no doubt wondering - how to apply the law to your own marcom efforts... (to be continued... coming soon...)


If you’d like to read more about the law of the unexpected and other means for cutting through the clutter, I highly recommend:

• Made to Stick: Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die

• Metaphorically Selling

read more

Marcom case study: the “Hyatt Shuttle” of New York’s Grand Central Station

It’s not often these days I’m stopped in my tracks (no pun intended) by an ad or related form of marketing communication. Most of them seem to fuse with the background becoming invisible in mere seconds. This week was an exception, however, and it underscores one of the core principles any marketer should keep in mind when crafting effective marketing communications…


My encounter with "The Shuttle"
As I boarded the Shuttle train this morning, half-awake from my morning coffee, I was brought to full attention by a completely transformed subway interior (for those unfamiliar, the shuttle is a train that runs between Time Square & Grand Central Station in NYC). Beyond the expected surprise I felt from entering a subway car that had been bathed in the accoutrement of a solitary theme, there were a few reasons in particular that made the experience so memorable. And, it serves as a great example of how marketers can cut through the clutter – objective number one for any marketing communication. This feat was all the more impressive given that it was competing head-to-head with the madness that is midtown Manhattan during morning rush hour.


Why the Hyatt Shuttle = effective marketing communication
So what made the experience so compelling?

For starters, the train’s interior broke any existing schema (or expectation) I had for “what the inside of a NYC subway looks like”. Instead of steely, cool panels, the train was affixed with faux wood “wall paper” reminiscent of some bachelor’s finished basement from the late 70s, pool table & wet bar not included.

In place of slick, high-design ads pressed into the metal picture frames that dot the subway’s interior were color graphs printed on basic white printer paper; graphs that reminded me of the simple bar charts Microsoft Excel spit out circa 1989 . The charts, whose effectiveness was heightened by their simplicity, depicted how much more successful face-to-face meetings are in comparison with video conferencing, email, or phone calls.

At its essence, Hyatt transformed a cold, unfriendly space (the inside of a NYC subway) into a warm, inviting place - the inference being that Hyatt Conference Centers create the type of warm, inviting atmospheres conducive to effective business schmoozing & networking.

Now I’m neither an event planner nor coordinator of large-scale meetings, so I cannot speak to the level of influence "The Hyatt Shuttle” might have on my decision-making for those upcoming conferences.

However, to some degree that’s irrelevant. “The Hyatt Shuttle” compelled me to whip out my blackberry on a crowded train and snap away - much to the annoyance of my fellow commuters. It got me to write this post with blurry crackberry photos attached for the entire world to see (or 0.00022% of the Internet world per my latest Alexa rankings). And perhaps most compelling - Hyatt was able to convert me into an online PR guy who’s apparently willing to work for free. All Hyatt had to do was serve up a unique experience that added a little bit of zest to my otherwise predictable day. Clever, high-ROI strategy… and heck of a marketing communications case study for marketers to sink their teeth into & leverage for their own business.


The Law of the Unexpected
Let’s bubble-up this mini case study and see what useful principles we can derive for you to use in your business… at its core, what made The Hyatt Shuttle so compelling is that it successfully employed the law of the unexpected, which simply states that throw something out there that I don’t expect and you’ll capture my attention... think giraffe in a field of cows, an orange in a bowl of apples, or your waiter at The Four Seasons dressed in a white t-shirt & cut-off jean shorts.


How to apply the law of the unexpected to your marketing communication
Let's get right to what you're no doubt wondering - how to apply the law to your own marcom efforts... (to be continued... coming soon...)


If you’d like to read more about the law of the unexpected and other means for cutting through the clutter, I highly recommend:

• Made to Stick: Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die

• Metaphorically Selling

read more

Show-Don't-Tell Marketing: enhance your marketing communications by using "picture-words"

"Show, don't tell!"
Yes, that annoying piece of feedback you received from your your 6th grade English teacher in creative writing class is as important for marketers to practice as it is for writers of fiction.

Let’s illustrate the point by looking at the following tag lines:

• "Use Lowenstein’s fertilizer and ensure the health & vitality of your lawn!"
• "Use Lowenstein’s fertilizer – it’ll make your lawn so green, so thick, and so soft you’ll ditch your bed and sleep outside on your grass!"

So how do these two tag lines differ? (Other than the 1 sentence vs. 2 sentence thing)

Unlike tag line 2, you can’t see tag line 1 in your mind’s eye. T1 uses non-visual, conceptual words like "health" and "vitality". T2 goes the visual route. It paints a picture in your head - you sleeping on a plush bed of the greenest grass.

Tag line 2 brings the benefits of Lowenstein’s fertilizer to life. Tag line 1 requires that YOU bring it to life, which requires mental energy – a non-starter for today’s consumers.

An easy tool for improving your sales & marketing copy

Step 1 - Assess
Take your sales copy, email campaign, landing page or what have you, and ask:

• Do the words paint a picture in my mind? How vivid is that picture?
• Does the picture clearly express the core benefit of my product? (Why paint a beautiful picture that doesn’t help sell your product?)

Step 2 - Identify
Identify the conceptual/abstract words in your copy – those words that don't paint clear pictures in your head.

Step 3 - Improve
Take the list of conceptual words you identified in Step 2 and do either of the following:

• Replace these conceptual words with visual counterparts
• Add visual words to your copy that bring your conceptual words to life. For example, if you're using the word "healthy", you can add visual words like "32-inch waistline", "glowing, beautiful skin", "well-sculpted muscles", etc.

In closing... whether your 6th grade English teacher had strong coffee breath, a grating voice, or a curious way of holding his chalk, when he shouted those three little words, “Show, Don’t Tell!” he was speaking the Marketing Gospel. Heed his words. Because if the consumer can't see the benefits he'll receive from your product, the consumer won't buy it. Amen.

read more

Show-Don't-Tell Marketing: enhance your marketing communications by using "picture-words"

"Show, don't tell!"
Yes, that annoying piece of feedback you received from your your 6th grade English teacher in creative writing class is as important for marketers to practice as it is for writers of fiction.

Let’s illustrate the point by looking at the following tag lines:

• "Use Lowenstein’s fertilizer and ensure the health & vitality of your lawn!"
• "Use Lowenstein’s fertilizer – it’ll make your lawn so green, so thick, and so soft you’ll ditch your bed and sleep outside on your grass!"

So how do these two tag lines differ? (Other than the 1 sentence vs. 2 sentence thing)

Unlike tag line 2, you can’t see tag line 1 in your mind’s eye. T1 uses non-visual, conceptual words like "health" and "vitality". T2 goes the visual route. It paints a picture in your head - you sleeping on a plush bed of the greenest grass.

Tag line 2 brings the benefits of Lowenstein’s fertilizer to life. Tag line 1 requires that YOU bring it to life, which requires mental energy – a non-starter for today’s consumers.

An easy tool for improving your sales & marketing copy

Step 1 - Assess
Take your sales copy, email campaign, landing page or what have you, and ask:

• Do the words paint a picture in my mind? How vivid is that picture?
• Does the picture clearly express the core benefit of my product? (Why paint a beautiful picture that doesn’t help sell your product?)

Step 2 - Identify
Identify the conceptual/abstract words in your copy – those words that don't paint clear pictures in your head.

Step 3 - Improve
Take the list of conceptual words you identified in Step 2 and do either of the following:

• Replace these conceptual words with visual counterparts
• Add visual words to your copy that bring your conceptual words to life. For example, if you're using the word "healthy", you can add visual words like "32-inch waistline", "glowing, beautiful skin", "well-sculpted muscles", etc.

In closing... whether your 6th grade English teacher had strong coffee breath, a grating voice, or a curious way of holding his chalk, when he shouted those three little words, “Show, Don’t Tell!” he was speaking the Marketing Gospel. Heed his words. Because if the consumer can't see the benefits he'll receive from your product, the consumer won't buy it. Amen.

read more

Improve your marcom by becoming mindful of messages that hit you in the gut!

One of the most powerful pieces of communication I have ever laid my eyes upon was not the brainchild of the hot, new Madison Avenue agency... nor the creative genius of an underground, esoteric Parisian artist. It was the creation of a couple of public school teachers and their students. It sat on display in the entry hall of their school in Harlem.

There in the display case was a can of a Coca Cola and three Chips Ahoy cookies. Right next to the can of coke was a mountain of pure white sugar. The Chips Ahoy cookies were accompanied by a similar-sized mountain of sugar in addition to a large cube of butter.

The sign above the display read, "Ever wonder how much sugar is in that can of coke you're drinking?"

Needless to say, the hills of sugar and the butter represented the exact amounts of sugar and fat in the respective items on display. It was powerful communication. It scored a knockout blow.

The goal behind any communication is quite simple. Get people to notice it. Get people to "give it the time of day". Get people to be moved or motivated by it.

Whenever I come across something or someone that communicates powerfully, I stop and ask myself, "Why? What was it about this that made it past my 'filter' and touched me in some way?" Whatever answers I come up with, I try to boil down to more generalized themes that I can apply in some capacity to my own marketing efforts. As a marketer, this is an important habit to develop, and one that has helped me immeasurably throughout my career.

Going back to the school display in Harlem, the communication was effective with me for two primary reasons, each interrelated:

1. It was unexpected & surprising.
2. It made the abstract concrete.

While I knew a can of coke had 'lots of sugar' in it, the 'lots' remained an abstract concept that was hard for me to interpret - and one that I likely preferred not to think about. Translating this abstract concept into a visually compelling mound of sugar brought it to life, and made it easily comparable. How could I help but notice that the mound of sugar was 1/2 the height of the can of coke! It was a perverse, shocking image, with a powerful, long-lasting impact.

While my example of the coke can highlighted a couple common success drivers of powerful communications - surprise & tangibility - there are several other such drivers that have relative degrees of importance given the context of the communication. While understanding these drivers is helpful, it's even more important to become mindful of those communications that "get to you" - and to ask yourself, "why?" The nuances you will learn through your self reflection about what make communications powerful is where the real insight lies.

read more

Improve your marcom by becoming mindful of messages that hit you in the gut!

One of the most powerful pieces of communication I have ever laid my eyes upon was not the brainchild of the hot, new Madison Avenue agency... nor the creative genius of an underground, esoteric Parisian artist. It was the creation of a couple of public school teachers and their students. It sat on display in the entry hall of their school in Harlem.

There in the display case was a can of a Coca Cola and three Chips Ahoy cookies. Right next to the can of coke was a mountain of pure white sugar. The Chips Ahoy cookies were accompanied by a similar-sized mountain of sugar in addition to a large cube of butter.

The sign above the display read, "Ever wonder how much sugar is in that can of coke you're drinking?"

Needless to say, the hills of sugar and the butter represented the exact amounts of sugar and fat in the respective items on display. It was powerful communication. It scored a knockout blow.

The goal behind any communication is quite simple. Get people to notice it. Get people to "give it the time of day". Get people to be moved or motivated by it.

Whenever I come across something or someone that communicates powerfully, I stop and ask myself, "Why? What was it about this that made it past my 'filter' and touched me in some way?" Whatever answers I come up with, I try to boil down to more generalized themes that I can apply in some capacity to my own marketing efforts. As a marketer, this is an important habit to develop, and one that has helped me immeasurably throughout my career.

Going back to the school display in Harlem, the communication was effective with me for two primary reasons, each interrelated:

1. It was unexpected & surprising.
2. It made the abstract concrete.

While I knew a can of coke had 'lots of sugar' in it, the 'lots' remained an abstract concept that was hard for me to interpret - and one that I likely preferred not to think about. Translating this abstract concept into a visually compelling mound of sugar brought it to life, and made it easily comparable. How could I help but notice that the mound of sugar was 1/2 the height of the can of coke! It was a perverse, shocking image, with a powerful, long-lasting impact.

While my example of the coke can highlighted a couple common success drivers of powerful communications - surprise & tangibility - there are several other such drivers that have relative degrees of importance given the context of the communication. While understanding these drivers is helpful, it's even more important to become mindful of those communications that "get to you" - and to ask yourself, "why?" The nuances you will learn through your self reflection about what make communications powerful is where the real insight lies.

read more

Use your customer's language so they can HEAR you

"... all I need is some cigarettes, a little food, and my HBO..."

-Anonymous gentleman on downtown #1 train, NYC

Well you certainly have to respect a guy who knows exactly what he wants. I wish I had his level of clarity...

I heard the above quote on the 2 train this morning during my work commute down to the World Financial Center, and it really slammed home a point that Sam Horn makes in her wonderful book, Pop! The key insight is to use your own customer's language in your marketing communications. Rather than playing around with formal-sounding or hip-sounding terminology, listen to the actual words that come out of your customers' mouths.

What do your customers say or think to themselves when they're in a situation in which they would benefit from your product (or service)? What do they say or think when they're enjoying the benefits of your product? What words do they use to describe the product to their friends?

Why pay an expensive copywriter or worse, try to write the copy yourself when you have thousands or millions of customers doing the writing for you already? And remember, perhaps the easiest way to gain access to the language of your customers is via the web - blogs, discussion boards, etc.

If you want your copy to sound real and resonate with your prospects & customers, what better way to accomplish this than to take the words straight from the horses' mouths?

read more

Wilton Stentz, the Yoda of online marketing...

All marketers know how important successful communication is - whether you're trying to build brand awareness, maintain the loyalty of an existing customer base, or influence key decision makers at work.

The Law of Association
While there are several core 'laws' that underlie successful communications, few are as crucial and as powerful as the law of association.

The law of association is based on the solid yet simple notion that in order to communicate effectively with anyone, you need to work with the material that already exists inside of their heads. Al Ries & Jack Trout underscored this premise in their classic book, Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind.

The law of association is particularly powerful when you are introducing something new to people, especially when it is complex, hard to "size up" or hard to visualize. Through using what is already in people's heads, you can instantly communicate in a manner that is both clear & compelling.

Who the heck is Wilton Stentz?
Let's use the title of this article as an example of the law in action. Now you probably don't know who Wilton Stentz is, but you most certainly know our friend, Yoda. Let's imagine that Mr. Stentz is a wise & experienced online marketing consultant who lives in Zurich. Now I could simply say these very words to you and you would be able to comprehend them; whether you would really hear them & remember them is a different matter. But when I look into your mind to identify something that represents wisdom & experience in a rich & visually compelling way, I come up with an association that immediately brings Mr. Stentz's attributes to life. When Wilton is compared to Yoda - in an instant - you "get it".

"It's the Rolls Royce of..."
To touch upon a few additional examples, you've probably heard the law of association used with respect to a a famous luxury automobile brand. Ever had someone tell you, "It's the Rolls Royce of... so-and-so"? Or, how about the brilliant use of the law by baby toy manufacturer, Baby Einstein? What parents don't want their children to become as brilliant as Albert Einstein?

Looking at current events you can see the law of association playing out in the presidential primaries on the Republican side. Just have a look at what Fred Thompson has tried to do, attempting to associate himself with former President Reagan. Perhaps it was a clever idea; however, one requirement that Fred seems to have overlooked is that the law requires there to be real integrity behind the association that is made. There is no substitute for this requirement, nor will there ever be.

The law of association has a rich and varied set of applications within communications, and I look forward to exploring them in future posts.

read more